The Best Oyster & Talisker Whisky Pairings

This is a sponsored post by Talisker Single Malt Scotch Whisky. All reviews and opinions expressed in this post are based on my personal view. Please drink responsibly.

Discovering new pairings can be just as thrilling as trying new oysters, and whisky is my next frontier. Even as a beginner, it's not difficult to recognize flavor combinations that are simply brilliant.

When Talisker, the iconic Single Malt Scotch Whisky brand from the Isle of Skye in Scotland, invited me to learn more about their story and why their whiskies pair so well with oysters, I happily jumped at the opportunity.

Photo courtesy of Talisker Whisky.

Photo courtesy of Talisker Whisky.

Why does Talisker Whisky pair so well with oysters?

I'll give you a hint: Talisker's tagline is "Made by the sea."

You know that adage, "What grows together, goes together"? It's also true in this case.

Just like oysters, whiskies have provenance. The location and different phases of the whisky-making process influence the final flavor, embodying its environment's essence. The Talisker Single Malt Scotch Whisky distillery is the oldest distillery on the Isle of Skye in Scotland. It's nestled along the seaweed-laden shores of Loch Harport, against the majestic Cuillin Hills.

I haven't been to the Isle of Skye yet, but friends who have made the trek say that it's a rugged, mysterious, and beautiful place. Sounds simply irresistible, right? If you're lucky enough to visit the distillery, be sure to enjoy some fresh oysters with your Talisker at the nearby The Oyster Shed. Or, if you happen to live in Scotland, you can order the limited edition Talisker & Oyster Signature Pairing Kit from Loch Fyne.

Oysters play a pivotal role in the Talisker story in more ways than one. Talisker has also partnered up with my favorite oyster-related non-profit, The Billion Oyster Project, to bolster their oyster reef restoration efforts as the lead sponsor of the Shell Collection Program.

2020-10-20 09.24.42 1.jpg

Oyster and whisky matchmaking: creating perfect companions

Talisker Single Malts are well-loved for their complex, briny and alluring sweet-smoky notes. Here is a simple guide to the different categories of flavors you'll taste in whiskies if you're a whisky novice like myself.

The trick to a good pairing is to create harmony, or at best, synergy. Finding oyster and whisky pairings that work well took a little experimentation. I tried two malts with an assortment of oysters from all across North America to determine which appellations or flavor profiles paired the best.

Talisker 10 Year Old

Talisker 10-Year-Old offers a rich tasting experience, with dried-fruit sweetness, clouds of smoke, intense barley-malt flavors, and peppery notes at the back of the mouth. As a whisky novice, I found the Talisker 10 Year Old to be wonderfully robust yet surprisingly approachable.

My favorite oyster pairings with Talisker 10 Year Old:

  • East Beach Blonde from Ninigret Pond, Rhode Island

  • Fishers Island from Block Island Sound, New York

  • Saint Simon, New Brunswick, Canada

  • Agate Pass Pearl from Port Madison, Washington 

Talisker Storm

Talisker Storm offers mellow and rich, then very spicy tasting notes with a pure tongue-coating sweetness & a nutty smokiness that embraces the spicier notes. To me, this malt is not for the faint of palate! A sip of Talisker Storm feels like swan-diving into the crashing waves. It's intense and exhilarating!

My favorite oyster pairings with Talisker Storm:

  • White Stone, North Point, Virginia

  • Stormy Bay, Delaware Bay, New Jersey

  • Wellfleet, Wellfleet Harbor, Massachusetts

The most versatile oyster pairings were with the Talisker 10-Year-Old Single Malt. Talisker Storm took more trial and error but was very rewarding when pairings worked. Oysters with lower salinity (15-22 ppt) and fuller meats tended to work better with Talisker Storm. In contrast, Talisker 10 Year Old matched nicely with moderate to high salinity oysters (23-30 ppt)—Atlantic (C. virginica) oysters were easier to pair than the Pacific (C. gigas) species. However, I imagine that Pacific oysters raised in Atlantic waters (like in Scotland) would also be an excellent match. Although I did not have an opportunity to try these malts with other species, such as the European Native and Olympia, I suspect that they would be interesting as well. 

For more pairing ideas, Talisker put together this sweet little Oyster and Talisker Pairing Guide below! 

How to enjoy oysters and whisky together

There are many ways to experience an oyster and whisky pairing.

Method #1 Sip, slurp, sip

This method shines the spotlight on the whisky a bit more than the oyster. Skip the initial sip if you want to taste more of the oyster. 

  • First, take a sip of whisky.

  • Then slurp (remember to chew) the oyster.

  • Finish with another sip of whisky.

Method #2 Spritz (or drip) and slurp

This method allows you to use the whisky more as an accouterment.

  • Lightly spritz the oyster with the whisky using an atomizer.

  • You can also use a dropper to add two or three drops of whisky onto the oyster.

Method #3 Sip, slurp, shell

This method is my favorite because it's so ritualistic! 

  • Take a sip of Talisker, let it swirl around on your palate.

  • Then slurp and savor the oyster.

  • Finally, pour a tiny bit of whisky into the oyster shell and drink.

  • Cheers with the shell if you'd like.

In conclusion, oysters and Talisker whisky make a very cheeky, soulful, and purposeful pairing. To learn more about Talisker, check out their profile on Malts.com, or follow their Instagram @talisker.